Skip to Content

“Banks force-placed insurance practices under microscope”

Sun Mar 31, 2013 by on News & Press Releases

If you haven’t heard about force-placed insurance before, there’s a pretty good chance you will be hearing a lot about it soon.

Though the practice has been around for several years, it’s only recently been making headlines in numerous national publications as regulators have finally decided it was high time to crack down on what only can be called self-dealing and fraudulent activities.

Force placed, as the name suggests, is a bank insurance product that big banks, lenders and loan servicers essentially force homeowners to purchase if they either allow their own policy to lapse – often the result of financial difficulties – or if the lender determines that the insurance the homeowner does have in place is insufficient.

And therein lies the rub:  While force-placed insurance premiums initially were supposed to be lower, so that the homeowner could afford to maintain the required insurance, investigations revealed that premiums were two to ten times higher and the force-placed insurance provided far less protection than any policy the homeowner would purchase were they able to afford it in the first place.

Last week, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo announced that his state’s Department of Financial Services reached a settlement with one of the country’s largest force-placed insurers – Assurant Inc.

According to a press release agreement calls for Assurant to do the following:

  • Make a $14 million settlement payment, without admitting or denying any wrongdoing.
  • Modify certain lender-placed business practices consistent with new regulations expected to be issued by the NYDFS that will apply to all New York-licensed lender-placed insurers of properties in the state.
  • File its new lender-placed program and new rates in New York.
  • Establish a refund opportunity program to be administered by an independent third party, through which New York property owners with ASIC or ABIC polices issued on or after Jan. 1, 2008 may be eligible for refunds of a portion of their premiums.

The investigation revealed what has been referred to as a “web” of complex arrangements between banks and insurers, which at the end of the day resulted in kickbacks to the banks and huge profits for the insurance companies. According to published reports, New York regulators found nearly 15 percent of the premiums from force-placed policies went back to the banks.

In the real world, that would be called racketeering. But as we all know banks don’t operate in the real world, but in their own protected world where they not only are “too big to fail” but as U.S. Attorney Eric Holder recently admitted, too big to jail.

While the settlement is a start, it doesn’t do much for those who lost their homes because they could not afford the insurance that was forcibly jammed down their throats. About half of the foreclosures handled by our firm have involved some form of force-placed insurance.

The Assurant agreement is, by far, the most significant regulatory action to date and a day after its announcement comes word that the Federal Housing Finance Agency, which regulates mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, plans to ban forced-placed insurance practices across the board.

Despite the $14 million slap on the wrist, Assurant isn’t ready to give up its force-placed lending practices and go home. In fact, in its press release announcing the settlement Assurant’s president and CEO notes: “We look forward to filing our next generation lender-placed product …”

Stay tuned!

Meet Florida’s leading real estate and foreclosure defense attorney, Roy Oppenheim. An experienced professional who traded Wall Street for Main Street and founded, Oppenheim Lawand Weston Title with his partner and wife, Ellen in 1989. As one of the leading Florida law firms, their reputation has earned them the highest rating (A-V) conferred by Martindale Hubbell® Law Directory, the most respected directory of lawyers and law firms in the U.S. Noted as a technical and skilled legal blogger, Oppenheim founded The South Florida Law Blog (Best Business and Technology blog, South Florida Sun-Sentinel) and is a contributor in Yahoo! HomesUS News and World ReportsHuffPost Live and many others.Twitter at @OpLaw or like Oppenheim Law onFacebook.